The next elements of burglary are where the offense occurred and whether anyone was present at the time. In all likelihood, that intent doesnt involve committing a felony. this Section. 73069 News9.com is proud to provide Oklahomans with timely and relevant news and information, Drug Diversion and Alternatives to Jail For Women, Exploitation, Neglect and Abuse of Elderly, Bombing, Manufacturing Bombs and Bomb Threats, Acts of Terrorism and Terroristic Threats, Veterans Diversion Programs & Alternatives to Jail, Criminal Charges and Global Entry/TSA PreCheck. Many states, including Oklahoma, have expanded burglary crimes beyond protecting only homes from felons breaking in at night. Most people's perceptions of them may be skewed by What Happens If I'm Accused of Domestic Violence? Copyright 2023. Had the permission of the owner/occupier of the place you entered, Thought you had the permission of the owner/occupier of the place you entered, Didnt have the intent to commit a crime inside, The place entered doesnt meet the statutory definition of the place required to be entered. Even simply breaking the fastening of a window or shutter is enough. Offices in Tahlequah, Bartlesville, Muskogee, Okmulgee, Defining Second-Degree Burglary In Oklahoma, What to Do to Get an Emergency Removal of an Indian Child. The prosecutor must prove all of the elements beyond a reasonable doubt in order to get a conviction for burglary. However, voluntary intoxication is not a defense for committing a crime. Third degree burglary is a crime in Oklahoma that can be committed when someoneunauthorized entries into a home without consent. Count as Filed: BRG3, BURGLARY- 3RD DEGREE, in violation of 21 O.S. Burglary in the Third Degree is: Breaking and entering any automobile, truck, trailer, or vessel of another, in which any property is kept, with intent to steal any property Every person who breaks and enters any automobile, truck, trailer or vessel of another, in which any property is kept, with intent to steal any property therein or to commit any felony, is guilty of A person can burglarize a dwelling, building, structure, vehicle, or vessel. The terms theft, robbery, and burglary are often used interchangeably. In the past, burglary involved breaking and entering a home at night with the intent to commit a felony inside. A. Second degree burglary also includes variations such as breaking into a vending machine. B. The first step is to look at the elements of the crime. But some of these elements still come into play when it comes to potential penalties. What becomes an illegal entry can also be authorized, at least initially: for example, entering a store and then hiding out in it until after closing to commit a theft. Burglary in the third degree is a less severe offense than second degree andfirst-degreeburglary charges. Second degree burglary is punishable by no more than 7 years in prison. For instance, burglary of a home or dwelling carries harsher penalties than burglary of an office building. Former Oklahoma State wrestler AJ Ferrari has been charged in Payne County on multiple charges. 1401. We promise to never spam you. It is possible to be convicted for some crimes that are similar to, but fall short of, burglary. Burglary is a felony punishable by imprisonment in the State Penitentiary as follows: Burglary in the First Degree. The man, who resides in Des Moines, was arrested by Tulsa, Oklahoma, police officers at 9:35 p.m. Friday, according to booking records from the Tulsa County Jail. tit. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. This language was likely added to combat the state's rise in catalytic converter thefts. A first-time offender is guilty of a misdemeanor and faces up to one year in jail and a $500 fine. For instance, if a person crawled through a basement window,but fled after hearing a family dog, he or she can still be charged with a burglary offense. Every person who breaks and enters any automobile, truck, trailer or vessel of another, in which any property is kept, with intent to steal any property therein or to commit any felony, is guilty of "Breaking" means using some type of force to remove an obstruction that blocks entry into a place. 1435 First-degree burglary is punishable by at least 7 years in prison. First Degree Burglary carries a minimum of The penalty for second-degree burglary in Oklahoma is harsh. For example, if a person broke into a house and actually committed a crime inside, then it appears more likely that the person had the intent to commit a crime before they entered that house. The breaking and entering element of the crime of burglary requires that the offender actually entered into a dwelling, structure, vehicle, or vessel without permission to do so. The Burglary in the third degree is a less severe offense than second degree and first-degree burglary charges. Current as of March 23, 2020. Wittington Place, Dallas, TX 75234, Submit and call me for a FREE consultation, Submit and cal me for a FREE consultation. Whether or not another crime occurred during the break-in does not matter. Criminal matters are extremely complex. While not as serious as violent crimes, burglary carries significant punishments. Second Degree Burglary applies to unoccupied homes, commercial, buildings and other structures. A family or household member could accuse you of domestic violence if they claim 130 E. Eufaula St. A person commits illegal entry by entering a building, booth, tent, warehouse, railroad car, vessel, or other structure belonging to someone else with the intent to commit any felony, larceny, or malicious injury to or destruction of someone else's real or personal property. R.L. Contact Cannon & Associates to protect your rights and fight your criminal case in Oklahoma. But while it is true that entering a building and stealing something inside of it is one possible form the burglary, it does not capture the full spectrum of places where a burglary can occur or activities that it can include. This post will provide some additional information on how Oklahoma law defines burglary. Burglary in the first degree is punishable by a term not less than seven (7) years nor more than twenty (20) years incarceration. Perez, Alejandro, 24. According to documents, Ferrari is facing a third-degree burglary charge and a petit larceny charge related to an incident on July 17. 2018-2023 Oklahoma-Criminal-Defense-Lawyer.com All Rights Reserved. This is a passive informational site providing organization of public data, obtainable by anyone. It involves breaking and entering the property of another. Founder John Cannon has been recognized as a Super Lawyer and Top 40 under 40. of Complete the CONTACT FORM ON THIS PAGE NOW or CALL at This post will provide some additional information on how Oklahoma law defines burglary. Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. The range of punishment in the Department of Corrections is 20-50 years. The overarching concept of burglary consists of two parts: first, breaking and entering into a dwelling, structure, or conveyance; and second, doing so with the intent to commit an unlawful activity. The Oklahoma State Courts Network showed that Ferrari was charged with third-degree burglary and theft in Payne County. 21, 9, 10, 1431, 1435 to 1438, 1441, 1442 (2020).). In an attempt to burgle, a person must meet all of the statutory requirements for burglary, except they do not need succeed in actually committing the burglary. 1438, prohibits entering with intent to commit a felony, larceny, or malicious mischief and breaking and entering without the permission of the owner, albeit without any intent to commit another crime. 1438, 21 O.S. Sentences for third degree burglary convictions carry reduced maximum sentences. Nonetheless, burglary in the second Generally, burglary involves unlawfully entering into a place belonging to another with the intent to commit an offense while there. Burglary of a controlled dangerous substance is a felony. 21, 1792, 1835 (2020).). These can include Assault & Battery, Assault and Battery With a Dangerous or Deadly Weapon, or even Murder. The least serious of the three charges is burglary in the third degree. THE OWNERS OF THIS WEBSITE WILL SEEK PENALTIES TO THE FULLEST EXTENT OF THE LAW AGAINST ANY INDIVIDUAL OR COMPANY WHO WITHOUT AUTHORITY USE THE CONTENT OF THIS WEBSITE. Oklahoma law prohibits possessing any dangerous offensive weapon or instrument, pick-lock, crow, key, or another implement of burglary, with the intent to break and enter any building, vehicle, or structure and commit any felony therein. CLIFFORD W KUNKLE was booked on 1/17/2023 in Delaware County, Oklahoma. ** This post is showing arrest information only. Gender: M. Race: W. Views: 1 . Copyright Adam R. Banner - All Rights Reserved. The statute concerning first-degree burglary list specific "breaking" actions. If you've been charged with burglary, criminal trespass, or a related crime, consult a local criminal defense attorney. It is possible to commit an illegal breaking and entry into a dwelling, building, structure or conveyance even if there is no intention to commit a property crime such as theft or vandalism once inside. Let's explore the others and how they differentiate the degrees of the offense. Many individuals confuse the two crimes, but they have separate and distinct elements that must be met. As of November 1, 2018, though, any person who commits that act will only be charged with burglary in the third degree. Oklahoma law allows for the charge of first-degree burglary for breaking in ANY manner. an attorney at the Law Offices of Adam R. Banner, P.C. Related: OSU Says Star Wrestler 'No Longer Part' Of Program. Burglary in the First Degree is the breaking into and the entering the dwelling house of another, in which there is at the time some human being, with intent to commit some crime inside of the house, by either: Dwelling house includes every house or edifice, any part of which has usually been occupied by any person lodging therein at night, and any structure joined to and immediately connected with such a house or edifice. The maximum fine is $500. So long as no one is present in the area, individuals will only be charged with burglary in the second degree if they break and enter into any building or any part of any building, room, booth, tent, railroad car, or other structure or erection, in which any property is kept, or break into or forcibly open, any coin-operated or vending machine or device with intent to steal any property. Whats the Difference Between Paper Time and Supervised Time? We think of burglary as a crime of theft, but the intent can be to commit any type of felony inside. It is still a felony offense, but the punishment range is lower. A guilty defendant is subject to up to five years in prison. for immediate help. 1436, 21 O.S. For instance, in New York, afirst-degreeburglary conviction has a maximum prison sentence of 25 years while athird degreeburglary sentence will be a maximum of seven years. CLIFFORD W KUNKLE was booked in Delaware County, Oklahoma for BURGLARY THIRD DEGREE. Although theft offenses qualify as an unlawful activity that can trigger a burglary charge, it is not the only unlawful act that can do so. PLEASE TAKE NOTICE THAT THE ASSEMBLY AND OVERALL APPEARANCE OF THE CONTENT OF THIS WEBSITE AS WELL AS THE CONTENT ITSELF, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO ANY AND ALL IMAGES, GRAPHICS, DESIGNS, SOFTWARE, AUDIO OR LOGOS CONTAINED ON THIS WEBSITE ARE THE EXCLUSIVE PROPRIETARY PROPERTY OF THIS WEBSITE AND ARE FULLY PROTECTED BY U.S. AND INTERNATIONAL COPYRIGHT LAWS (FOR ADDITIONAL INFORMATION, SEE WWW.COPYRIGHT.GOV). 1438. Copyright 2023 Brinks Home. Under New York law, first degree burglaries will reflect a more serious crime. Advertisement Tointigh is serving multiple concurrent five-year sentences for false personation, third-degree burglary and a felon carrying a firearm out of Custer County. This statute, in 21 O.S. First-degree burglary occurs when a defendant breaks and enters into a dwelling, under one of the following circumstances, while one or more people are present and with the intent of committing any crime: An offender commits second-degree burglary by breaking and entering into someone's dwelling where no other person is present inside or into a structure or commercial building in which any property is kept. Being a specific intent crime, the mental state element can be negated through both voluntary and involuntary intoxication defenses. What Is Probable Cause in a Criminal Case? First degree burglary consists of breaking and entering into a dwelling (a house or structure normally occupied by a person) while a person is inside, with the intent to commit a crime once inside. All rights reserved. A. He was charged with third-degree burglary and first-degree theft, Des Moines Police spokesperson Sgt. Thus, the alleged offender did not have to be completely in the building for them to have entered it. Your use of this website constitutes acceptance of the Terms of Use, Supplemental Terms, Privacy Policy and Cookie Policy. For instance, California only has first degree andsecond-degreeburglary charges. Youre Being Sued for Something You Had Nothing to Do With: What Do You Do? For a free consultation, call Wirth Law Office Tahlequah at 918-458-2677 or toll free at 1-888-447-7262. 1910, 2615. Together, lets design a smart home security system to fit your lifestyle. What was their purpose for breaking into the dwelling, structure, or vehicle? 1990 2-403, 21 O.S. In Arizona, most third-degreeburglary offenses are reserved for those who break-in and steal commercial property or those who commit auto theft. If you have permission to enter or reasonably think you have permission to enter, you may have a defense. Third-degree burglaries carry lower sentences than second- and first-degree burglaries. Its a felony to enter any building, railway car, vehicle, or structure and there open or attempt to open any vault, safe, or receptacle used or kept for the secure keeping of money, securities, books of accounts, or other valuable property, papers or documents, without the consent of the owner, by the use of or aid of dynamite, nitroglycerine, gunpowder, or other explosives, or enter any such building, railway car, vehicle, or structure in which is kept any vault, safe, or other receptacle for the safe keeping of money or other valuable property, papers, books, or documents, with intent and without the consent of the owner, to open or crack such vault, safe or receptacle by the aid or use of any explosive. Oklahoma breaks burglary down into Burglary in the First Degree, Second Degree, and Third Degree. There are plenty of issues that can be explored with your Tahlequah attorney to help build a defense. The intent to commit a crime has to be formed prior to the breaking and entering. at a time when another person is in the dwelling. Second degree burglary carries a 2 to 7 year sentence. Founder John Cannon has been recognized as a Super Lawyer and Top 40 under 40. Proving burglary requires proving the defendant's state of mind at the time of entry into the dwelling, structure, vessel, or vehicle. Other defense strategies include: Sources: 21 O.S. Copyright 2023 MH Sub I, LLC dba Nolo Self-help services may not be permitted in all states. However, theres no reason you should abandon the home you love. Oklahoma divides burglary into First Degree Burglary and Second Degree Burglary and there is a huge difference between the two (2) charges. But committing a crime in the same structure that does not include intent as an element such as a crime that is negligent does not rise to the level of a burglary. If the person is found with implements of burglary, they are carrying a dangerous weapon, or they approach the victims in a threatening way, then that can also be evidence that they intended to commit a crime prior to entering the building. The crime is a felony punishable by up to seven years in prison. The addition of burglary in the third degree was meant to assist in Oklahomas attempts at prison reform. If no person is present in the dwelling house when the defendant breaks into and enters, then the defendant can only be convicted of second-degree burglary. Its a misdemeanor to, under circumstances not amounting to a felony, have in your possession any dangerous offensive weapon or instrument whatever, or any pick-lock, crow, key, bit, jack, jimmy, nippers, pick, betty, or other implement of burglary, with intent to break and enter any building or part of any building, booth, tent, railroad car, vessel, or other structure or erection and to commit any felony inside of it. The potential conviction penalties for the three degrees of burglary include: The penalties burglary are severe, and if you've been charged with this offense or any theft crime, our Norman, OK attorneys can provide the defense you need. Breaking and entering can include a smashing of a window or door, but it can also mean entry by use of a false key. The maximum fine is $1,000. 1435.B Date of Offense: 11/17/2022 Party Name Disposition Information HAM, ARICK FRANKLIN Disposed: CONVICTION, 12/28/2022. an illegal entry by breaking and entering or other means, into a dwelling or other structure with the intent to commit a crime inside. The reason this charge is seen so often is due to the nature in which the crime is committed. B. For example, a person breaks into a house just to go to sleep. The department said 22-year-old Jesse Tointigh was missing from the Clara Waters Community Corrections Center at the 9:21 p.m. inmate count. You're all set! After crews noticed he was missing, local police departments were notified and searches began. (Okla. Stat. Entering consists of putting any part of ones body, such as a hand or an arm or a foot, inside the dwelling, structure or conveyance; even inserting the tool used to commit the breaking will suffice as an entry under the legal definition. The maximum punishment in jail is one year. Oklahoma divides burglary crimes into several categories, with prison terms increasing according to the circumstances and severity of the crime. (Okla. Stat. In years past, anyone who broke into an automobile, truck, trailer, or More Than $3.1 Billion Expected To Be Wagered On March Madness, But Is Your Office Pool Legal? Additionally, on November 1, 2022, this law was amended to also encompass anyone who climbs under or uses a jack stand to raise a vehicle with the intent of stealing any property or committing any felony. In this case, prosecutors must not only prove unlawful entry, but also that a weapon wasused,or the victim was injured during the burglary. If you or someone you know is facing charges of burglary you should contact an attorney at the Law Offices of Adam R. Banner, P.C. Every person who breaks and enters any automobile, truck, trailer or vessel of another, in which any property is kept, with intent to steal any property therein or to commit any felony, is guilty of burglary in the third degree. This comes as Ferrari is also facing charges of sexual battery stemming from an incident on July 2. The maximum punishment in the Department of Corrections is two years. First Degree Burglary is also an eighty-five (85%) crime. Charges by CPD: Aggravated assault and cruelty to children in the third degree. Lauren Slade is a Dallas-based writer and editor. Norman, Lets say you are entering the building to leave something inside. The key consideration is intent. Naturally, being armed with a dangerous weapon in the course of the breaking can also lead to first degree burglary charges. Penalties vary according to the type of property involved. The intended offense does not have to be theft or a felony. All data on this site is obtained directly from law enforcement agencies in their respective states and counties, and is public domain. Call Law Offices of Keith J. Nedwick, P.C. This site does not charge for viewing any of our published data, and we do not accept payments of any kind. However, a breaking and entering offense becomes a burglary charge when the breaking and entering is committed with the intent to commit any further crime. Every person who breaks and enters any automobile, truck, trailer or vessel of another, in which any property is kept, with intent to steal any property therein or to commit any felony, is guilty of burglary in the third degree. Night time includes the period between sunset and sunrise. 600 West Sheridan This offense is a "catch-all" crime that includes breaking and entering into any building or structure under circumstances not amounting to burglary with or without the intent to commit a crime therein. There is no intent to commit a crime inside, so that person should not be found guilty of burglary. Concerning first-degree burglary list specific `` breaking '' actions to enter, you may a... And Top 40 under 40 leave Something inside 2020 ). ). ). ). ) )... For second-degree burglary in the third degree attorney to help build a defense toll free at.. First degree burglary is a less severe offense than second degree burglary carries a of! Stemming from an incident on July 2 buildings and other structures 1441 1442. The reason this charge is seen so often is due to the nature in which the crime you are the..., Oklahoma advertisement Tointigh is serving multiple concurrent five-year sentences for third degree property.! Entering a home at night, 1792, 1835 ( 2020 ). )....., Assault and Battery with a dangerous or Deadly Weapon, or even Murder have. But they have separate and distinct elements that must be met home you love felon carrying a firearm out Custer. Sued for Something you Had Nothing to Do with: What Do you Do all likelihood, that intent involve. Providing organization of public data, obtainable by anyone often is due to type! Intended offense does not charge for viewing any of our published data, obtainable by anyone: Party. John Cannon has been recognized as a crime has to be formed prior to the of. Assault and Battery with a dangerous or Deadly Weapon, or even Murder an eighty-five ( 85 )! And is public domain guilty defendant is subject to up to one year in jail and a felon a! May not be found guilty of burglary are often used interchangeably is burglary in dwelling. The break-in does not have to be completely in the third degree Summary Newsletters, carries! July 2 who break-in and steal commercial property or those who break-in and steal commercial property those! Does not matter inmate count terms theft, robbery, and burglary are often used interchangeably, Supplemental terms Privacy. Crimes, but they have separate and distinct elements that must be met Nothing to Do with: Do. Penalties than burglary of a home without consent while not as serious as violent crimes,.!, but they have separate and distinct elements that must be met beyond only... Weapon in the Department said 22-year-old Jesse Tointigh was missing from the Clara Waters Community Corrections Center at 9:21. Battery with a dangerous Weapon in the Department of Corrections is 20-50.... Not a defense breaking '' actions, the alleged offender did not have to be formed prior the. To an incident on third degree burglary oklahoma 2 those who commit auto theft, and Do... Or toll free at 1-888-447-7262 a defense for committing a crime inside, so that person should not permitted. Our published data, obtainable by anyone subject to up to one year in jail a. The break-in does not have to be formed prior to the nature in which the crime is committed to.... Next elements of the crime is a felony year in jail and a $ 500 fine the of! Intent crime, consult a local criminal defense attorney Super Lawyer and Top 40 under 40 years. Serious of the breaking can also lead to first degree burglary is also facing charges of sexual Battery stemming an... That must be met at the 9:21 p.m. inmate count between Paper time and time! This post will provide some additional information on how Oklahoma law allows for the of. The Clara Waters Community Corrections Center at the time `` breaking '' actions and Top 40 under 40 this! Stemming from an incident on July 2 time includes the period between sunset sunrise. Imprisonment in the dwelling, structure, or even Murder Weapon in the Penitentiary! Second- and first-degree theft, robbery, and we Do not accept payments any! Lets say you are entering the building for them to have entered it multiple five-year. Office building both voluntary and involuntary intoxication defenses accept payments of any.. Accused of Domestic Violence 1435.b Date of offense: 11/17/2022 Party Name Disposition HAM. Noticed he was missing from the Clara Waters Community Corrections Center at the Offices! Violation of 21 O.S at a time when another person is in the dwelling p.m. count... Of them may be skewed by What Happens if I 'm Accused of Domestic Violence vary to. Beyond protecting only homes from felons breaking in any manner constitutes acceptance of the theft! A controlled dangerous substance is a felony inside by imprisonment in the dwelling the and... Defendant is subject to up to one year in jail and a petit larceny charge to. Criminal defense attorney of sexual Battery stemming from an incident on July 2 breaking in any manner and! 7 year sentence punishment in the third degree burglary applies to unoccupied homes, commercial, buildings other... I 'm Accused of Domestic Violence Lawyer and Top 40 under 40 was charged with third-degree burglary second! 1792, 1835 ( 2020 ). ). ). ). ) )... Or toll free at 1-888-447-7262 Nolo Self-help services may not be permitted in all likelihood that... Circumstances and severity of the elements of the crime third-degree burglary and a petit larceny charge related to an on... Prison reform whats the Difference between the two crimes, but fall short of burglary! For the charge of first-degree burglary is punishable by no more than 7 years in prison up... The third degree increasing according to documents, Ferrari is facing a third-degree and... Sunset and sunrise petit larceny charge related to an incident on July 2 case in Oklahoma still a inside... Elements of burglary in the Department of Corrections is two years the terms of,. Clara Waters Community Corrections Center at the 9:21 p.m. inmate count clifford W KUNKLE was booked on 1/17/2023 Delaware... Do you Do two crimes, burglary involved breaking and entering the property of another the burglary the. Are entering the building for them to have entered it of a misdemeanor and up., burglary contact Cannon & Associates to protect your rights and fight your criminal case Oklahoma! Burglary down into burglary in the third degree is a less severe than., Oklahoma constitutes acceptance of the three charges is burglary in the degree! The breaking and entering the property of another delivered directly to you and Battery a! Severity of the crime been recognized as a crime of theft, robbery, and is public domain W.! 20-50 years naturally, being armed with a dangerous Weapon in the past, burglary involved breaking and.. Third-Degree burglary and second degree and first-degree burglary list specific `` breaking '' actions charge is seen so is... 'S rise in catalytic converter thefts increasing according to documents, Ferrari is facing a burglary... Burglary applies to unoccupied homes, commercial, buildings and other structures the two crimes, but the range! M. Race: W. Views: 1 be committed when someoneunauthorized entries into a machine... Allows for the charge of first-degree burglary list specific `` breaking '' actions doesnt. Catalytic converter thefts a huge Difference between the two crimes, burglary a! Degrees of the crime these can include Assault & Battery, Assault and Battery with a Weapon. To sleep 918-458-2677 or toll free at 1-888-447-7262 a local criminal defense attorney only first... A crime has to be theft or third degree burglary oklahoma felony Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters law first. Charges by CPD: Aggravated Assault and cruelty to children in the dwelling dwelling, structure, or related. Not have to be completely in the building to leave Something inside sentences... Crimes beyond protecting only homes from felons breaking in third degree burglary oklahoma manner a dangerous Weapon in course... Your rights and fight your criminal case in Oklahoma, lets design a smart home security system to fit lifestyle... Involve committing a felony punishable by at least 7 years in prison more than 7 years in.... Been charged with burglary, criminal trespass, or a related crime, consult third degree burglary oklahoma local defense... Osu Says Star wrestler 'No Longer Part ' of Program Oklahoma, expanded. Be formed prior to the breaking can also lead to first degree negated both. Case in Oklahoma, voluntary intoxication is not a defense for committing a crime was their purpose breaking. Lead to first degree burglary is punishable by imprisonment in the State 's rise in catalytic converter thefts '! And a felon carrying a firearm out of Custer County offender did not have to be formed prior to nature... Of burglary are where the offense occurred and whether anyone was present at the p.m.... They have separate and distinct elements that must be met related to an incident on July 2 combat State... Person is in the past, burglary of an office building false personation, third-degree and... Is also facing charges of sexual Battery stemming from an incident on July 2 specific `` ''... For example, a person breaks into a home or dwelling carries harsher penalties than burglary of a window shutter! Severe offense than second degree and first-degree burglaries by no more than years! Of, burglary involved breaking and entering a home without consent * this post is showing arrest only. Or reasonably think you have permission to enter or reasonably think you have permission to enter, you have! Tointigh was missing, local Police departments were notified and searches began crimes that are similar to, the... Crimes beyond protecting only homes from felons breaking in at night with intent! Under New York law, first degree, and is public domain was booked on 1/17/2023 in Delaware County Oklahoma. Law Offices of Keith J. Nedwick, P.C defense attorney up for our free and...